Google Reviews
Read a story...
share a moment...
join the experience...
All our customers share something in common, Do you see it?
Jocelyn
If you’re wondering what delectable dessert to get, might I recommend the cherry pie?!?!!!? It’s so delicious. You won’t regret it!!!
Lauren
I am a huge fan of pumpkin bread, and the pumpkin muffins from My Story Cakes and Desserts are absolutely divine!! They are so moist and perfectly flavored, it took a lot of will-power to limit myself to one a day! Additionally, the owner is absolutely delightful, and you can taste the love baked into all of her creations. Highly recommended all the tasty treats coming out of her ovens!!
Ann
Tamara “ lemon bars “are the best I have ever tasted! When I travel I want go to different bakeries and try their lemon bars to compare hands-down Tamara has the best lemon bar I have ever tasted. When I was pregnant I would crave these lemon bars 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
Valencia
The LEMON BARS ARE ABSOLUTELY A-MAZING!!! I don’t even like lemon bars but when I tasted these…. WOW! It’s difficult to stop eating them!! The lemon flavor - the consistency- THE SHORTBREAD CRUST- I just don’t know how to fully describe them.Please treat yourself and try them. You will not be disappointed! The absolute best! If you pick some up they will probably not make it to your house if you taste them in the car. Luv Luv Luv!!!
Lakitia
The best lemon bars and pound cake! I absolutely love anything she bakes!
Bonnie
Tamara is hands down the best baker. For my birthday, there is nothing better than her caramel cake. It is delicious, moist, and flavorful. Likewise, for my wedding, we had a non-traditional table full of cakes and pies. Her lemon bars were gone so fast, I didn’t even get to eat one! She truly puts love into everything she bakes, and it shows in the her fabulous details.
Richard
Like everyone is saying already, the lemon bars are famous. I’m 32 now and I’ve been eating them since I was 16 years old. Whenever they’re around, within minutes they’ve been eaten. Had them at my wedding and they were gone in an instant. Also, the pound cake is amazing! Again, gone so fast because of how delicious it was. You cannot go wrong with anything you order!
Quinn
I have ordered from My Story Cakes numerous times and I cannot begin to tell you how delicious every. single. thing. has. been. Just the thought of those tiny little pound cakes makes my mouth water. I don’t even like pound cake that much! But this, THIS pound cake! It’s so good it could end a relationship because you would both be fighting over who gets the last one. I would fight to the death! No but really, that’s how good all of the desserts are. Highly recommend, love every single decadently made bite.